What this topic covers
Trading securities (quotes, orders, short sales, cash and margin accounts, market participants, trading costs, best execution, soft dollars) and portfolio performance measures (Part III.J-K of the Series 65 Test Specifications). These are original practice notes, not materials of NASAA or FINRA. References to the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 reflect the text in force on January 1, 2027; formulas are the standard ones of the syllabus.
Quotes and market participants
- Bid and ask: the bid is the highest price a buyer will pay, so it is where an investor sells; the ask is where a dealer sells. Spread = ask - bid: $24.85 - $24.60 = $0.25, or $125 on 500 shares.
- Market maker: a dealer holding itself out as willing to buy and sell a security for its own account on a regular or continuous basis (Section 3 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934); it acts as principal and earns the spread.
- Introducing vs clearing: an introducing broker-dealer takes orders; the clearing firm holds cash and securities and settles trades. A custodian holds assets without quoting a market.
- Principal vs agent: selling from inventory as principal earns a markup over the prevailing market price, ($27.50 - $25.00) x 400 = $1,000; a markdown applies when buying from a customer; an agent charges a commission.
- Payment for order flow: a payment to a broker-dealer for routing customer orders to a particular market maker or venue.
Orders, short sales and accounts
- Limit order: executes at its price or better.
- Sell stop: placed below the market; becomes a market order once the stock trades at or through the stop price, limiting the loss on a long position.
- Buy stop: placed above the market; becomes a market order to buy, covering a short position and capping its loss.
- Short sale: the seller borrows shares, profits when the price falls, generally needs a margin account, and faces a theoretically unlimited loss.
- Cash vs margin: a cash account pays the full price; in a margin account the customer borrows part of it, the securities are collateral, and a margin call may require more cash or securities.
Best execution and soft dollars
- Best execution: the most favorable overall terms reasonable under the circumstances: price, commission, speed and likelihood of execution.
- Safe harbor: paying more than the lowest commission is protected if the adviser determined in good faith that it was reasonable in relation to the value of the brokerage and research services (Section 28(e) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934).
- Eligible services: research and analyses, and effecting transactions with clearance, settlement and custody. Office rent and utilities are not eligible.
Return measures
- Holding period return = (ending price - beginning price + income) / beginning price: ($53 - $50 + $2) / $50 = 10.0%.
- Annualized return = (ending value / beginning value)^(1/years) - 1: ($13,310 / $10,000)^(1/3) - 1 = 10.0%.
- Time-weighted return: links subperiod returns between cash flows, so deposits and withdrawals do not affect it; it measures the manager (1.10 x 1.05 - 1 = 15.5%).
- Dollar-weighted return: the internal rate of return of the cash flows; it reflects the investor's timing.
- Expected return: probability-weighted average of scenarios: 0.25 x 24% + 0.50 x 6% + 0.25 x -8% = 7.0%.
- Real and after-tax: real = nominal - inflation; after-tax = return x (1 - tax rate): 8.0% x 0.70 = 5.6%.
Benchmarks
- Matching: a benchmark should match holdings: the S&P 500 for large-cap stocks, a broad investment-grade bond index for bonds, the Russell 2000 for small caps.
Sample questions (5)
1. In a securities quotation, the bid price is the:
- Price at which a dealer will sell the security to a buyer
- Highest price a buyer is currently willing to pay for it
- Difference between the buying price and the selling price
- Average of the highest and lowest prices of the trading day
The bid is the highest price a buyer is currently willing to pay, so it is the price at which an investor can sell. The price at which a dealer will sell is the ask, the difference between the two quotes is the spread, and an average of the day's high and low prices is not a quotation at all.
2. Under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, a dealer that holds itself out as willing to buy and sell a security for its own account on a regular or continuous basis is a:
- Introducing broker-dealer, forwarding orders to others
- Clearing broker-dealer, settling trades for other firms
- Market maker, quoting both a bid and an ask regularly
- Qualified custodian, holding client cash and securities
Section 3 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 defines a market maker as a dealer who holds itself out as “willing to buy and sell such security for his own account on a regular or continuous basis”. A clearing broker-dealer settles and carries accounts for other firms, an introducing broker-dealer takes orders but passes them to a clearing firm, and a custodian holds assets without quoting a market.
3. Which return measure removes the effect of the timing and size of a client's deposits and withdrawals, and is therefore used to judge a manager's skill?
- Dollar-weighted return, based on the account's cash flows
- Time-weighted return, linking the returns of subperiods
- Holding period return, based on one start and end value
- Current yield, dividing annual income by current price
The time-weighted return links the returns of the subperiods between cash flows, so deposits and withdrawals do not affect it, which makes it the standard measure of a manager's performance. The dollar-weighted return is the internal rate of return and reflects the client's timing, a single holding period return on the account mixes in the cash flows, and current yield measures income relative to price rather than total performance.
4. The dollar-weighted rate of return on an account is the same as its:
- Geometric average of the returns of each subperiod
- Arithmetic average of the account's annual returns
- Annual income divided by the current market price
- Internal rate of return on the account's cash flows
The dollar-weighted return equals the internal rate of return (IRR) of the account's cash flows, so it reflects the investor's own timing and size of deposits and withdrawals. Linking subperiod returns geometrically gives the time-weighted return, annual income over current price is the current yield, and a simple average of annual returns ignores both compounding and cash flows.
5. Soft dollar arrangements are BEST described as those in which an adviser:
- Charges its clients a flat annual fee instead of a percentage
- Uses client commissions to pay a broker for research and execution
- Pays for research directly out of its own funds, not commissions
- Receives a share of the commissions in return for client referrals
In a soft dollar arrangement the adviser causes client accounts to pay commissions that also cover research and other brokerage services from the executing broker, and Section 28(e) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 offers a safe harbor for eligible services. A flat fee is a fee structure, paying for research from its own funds is a hard dollar expense, and a share of commissions for referrals is a solicitation payment.